By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.
leave as an accommodation vs. FMLA leave
min read
Published on
October 21, 2025

Leave as an Accommodation vs. FMLA Leave: What Employers Need to Know

Updated on
October 21, 2025
leave as an accommodation vs. FMLA leave

Table of contents

When it comes to employee leave, the lines between different laws and processes can blur. Many HR teams assume that all leave requests fall under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). But in reality, leave can also be a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA).

Understanding the distinction matters—for compliance, for employee trust, and for avoiding costly legal risk.

FMLA leave: The basics

FMLA provides eligible employees with up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave for certain family and medical reasons. Key characteristics include:

  • Applies only to employers with 50+ employees within a 75-mile radius
  • Covers specific qualifying events (e.g., serious health condition, bonding with a new child, caring for a family member)
  • Employees must meet eligibility requirements (12 months of service, 1,250 hours worked)
  • The leave is time-bound and tracked

FMLA is a federal entitlement program—it doesn’t depend on a disability definition, and once conditions are met, employers must grant it.

Leave as an accommodation

Under the ADA or PWFA, an employee with a disability or pregnancy-related condition may request leave as a reasonable accommodation—even if they don’t qualify for or exhaust their FMLA entitlement.

Key differences:

  • No minimum service or hours worked requirement
  • Can apply to any size employer covered by the ADA/PWFA (15+ employees)
  • Leave may be intermittent, part-time, or extended—tailored to the employee’s needs
  • Must be granted unless it causes undue hardship to the employer

Most importantly, accommodation leave is not tied to an FMLA “bucket.” It can be requested at any point, and employers must consider it through the interactive process.

Why the confusion?

The overlap is where employers stumble:

  • An employee may use FMLA leave and later request additional leave as an accommodation
  • Some leave management tools only track FMLA (and similar state leave laws), leaving ADA/PWFA accommodation requests overlooked
  • HR teams trained primarily on leave may miss that accommodations require separate analysis, documentation, and compliance workflows

Risks of getting It wrong

Treating all leave as FMLA (or denying requests outside it) exposes employers to:

  • EEOC enforcement actions: Courts have consistently ruled that leave can be a reasonable accommodation.
  • Employee relations issues: Denying or mishandling requests erodes trust and can drive attrition.
  • Compliance gaps: Without tracking accommodations separately, employers lack visibility into patterns, costs, and risks.

Best practices for employers

  • Separate your processes: FMLA and ADA/PWFA leave requests should never be collapsed into one workflow.
  • Train managers and HR teams: Make sure they know leave may be a reasonable accommodation even when FMLA doesn’t apply.
  • Document the interactive process: Every request deserves individualized consideration, including alternatives to leave.
  • Invest in the right tools: Many leave platforms were built for FMLA compliance, not accommodations. True risk management requires systems that support both.

The bigger picture

Accommodations aren’t limited to time away—they can include schedule adjustments, remote work, or job restructuring. But when leave is the accommodation, employers must recognize it as such. Employees don’t stop needing support once their FMLA runs out, and the law requires more than a one-size-fits-all leave policy.

How Disclo helps

At Disclo, we specialize in accommodations management, not just leave tracking. Our platform ensures HR teams can distinguish between FMLA leave and leave as a reasonable accommodation, document the interactive process, and stay compliant with ADA and PWFA requirements.

Leave management vendors may help track FMLA, but accommodations can be requested anytime, for any qualifying condition. That’s why employers need a partner built for the nuances of accommodation—not just entitlement.

If you’re ready to understand how leave fits into the bigger accommodations picture, reach out to our team.

Related Articles

Left arrow
Back
leave as an accommodation vs. FMLA leaveleave as an accommodation vs. FMLA leave
leave as an accommodation vs. FMLA leave

Leave as an Accommodation vs. FMLA Leave: What Employers Need to Know

When it comes to employee leave, the lines between different laws (FMLA, ADA, PWFA) and processes can blur. Here's what employers need to know.

Team Disclo
October 21, 2025

When it comes to employee leave, the lines between different laws and processes can blur. Many HR teams assume that all leave requests fall under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). But in reality, leave can also be a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA).

Understanding the distinction matters—for compliance, for employee trust, and for avoiding costly legal risk.

FMLA leave: The basics

FMLA provides eligible employees with up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave for certain family and medical reasons. Key characteristics include:

  • Applies only to employers with 50+ employees within a 75-mile radius
  • Covers specific qualifying events (e.g., serious health condition, bonding with a new child, caring for a family member)
  • Employees must meet eligibility requirements (12 months of service, 1,250 hours worked)
  • The leave is time-bound and tracked

FMLA is a federal entitlement program—it doesn’t depend on a disability definition, and once conditions are met, employers must grant it.

Leave as an accommodation

Under the ADA or PWFA, an employee with a disability or pregnancy-related condition may request leave as a reasonable accommodation—even if they don’t qualify for or exhaust their FMLA entitlement.

Key differences:

  • No minimum service or hours worked requirement
  • Can apply to any size employer covered by the ADA/PWFA (15+ employees)
  • Leave may be intermittent, part-time, or extended—tailored to the employee’s needs
  • Must be granted unless it causes undue hardship to the employer

Most importantly, accommodation leave is not tied to an FMLA “bucket.” It can be requested at any point, and employers must consider it through the interactive process.

Why the confusion?

The overlap is where employers stumble:

  • An employee may use FMLA leave and later request additional leave as an accommodation
  • Some leave management tools only track FMLA (and similar state leave laws), leaving ADA/PWFA accommodation requests overlooked
  • HR teams trained primarily on leave may miss that accommodations require separate analysis, documentation, and compliance workflows

Risks of getting It wrong

Treating all leave as FMLA (or denying requests outside it) exposes employers to:

  • EEOC enforcement actions: Courts have consistently ruled that leave can be a reasonable accommodation.
  • Employee relations issues: Denying or mishandling requests erodes trust and can drive attrition.
  • Compliance gaps: Without tracking accommodations separately, employers lack visibility into patterns, costs, and risks.

Best practices for employers

  • Separate your processes: FMLA and ADA/PWFA leave requests should never be collapsed into one workflow.
  • Train managers and HR teams: Make sure they know leave may be a reasonable accommodation even when FMLA doesn’t apply.
  • Document the interactive process: Every request deserves individualized consideration, including alternatives to leave.
  • Invest in the right tools: Many leave platforms were built for FMLA compliance, not accommodations. True risk management requires systems that support both.

The bigger picture

Accommodations aren’t limited to time away—they can include schedule adjustments, remote work, or job restructuring. But when leave is the accommodation, employers must recognize it as such. Employees don’t stop needing support once their FMLA runs out, and the law requires more than a one-size-fits-all leave policy.

How Disclo helps

At Disclo, we specialize in accommodations management, not just leave tracking. Our platform ensures HR teams can distinguish between FMLA leave and leave as a reasonable accommodation, document the interactive process, and stay compliant with ADA and PWFA requirements.

Leave management vendors may help track FMLA, but accommodations can be requested anytime, for any qualifying condition. That’s why employers need a partner built for the nuances of accommodation—not just entitlement.

If you’re ready to understand how leave fits into the bigger accommodations picture, reach out to our team.

Curious to see how accommodations can support your employees?

Schedule a free demo today.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share this article
Related Articles